feat(ai-judge): rework enforce mode as user-assumed-risk contract

- add config v2 with fixed judge model selection and fail-closed v1 enforce migration to shadow
- add built-in high-risk override for irreversible, publish, system, and credential shapes that always defers to the human
- remove the promotion gate, promotion records tool, and their tests
- fail closed with judge_model_unavailable when a configured judge model cannot be resolved
- notify once per session in enforce mode with the judge model and risk contract
- add ADR 0008 and update README and CONTEXT
This commit is contained in:
2026-08-21 23:11:40 +08:00
parent f4ba739878
commit 061c60c344
17 changed files with 1372 additions and 1137 deletions
+20 -5
View File
@@ -8,11 +8,16 @@ extensions that inspect and re-evaluate Bash commands before they are allowed.
### Authority
**Enforce authority**:
Allow-only delegation — when the Judge's verdict is `allow` and every gate in
the Enforce truth table passes, the command runs without the human dialog. The
Judge can never answer `deny` with authority; every uncertain case (defer,
deny, preflight, infrastructure failure) falls back to the human dialog.
_Avoid_: AI takeover, auto-deny, full delegation
Allow-only delegation under a user-assumed-risk contract (ADR 0008):
writing `mode: "enforce"` in config v2 consents to the selected judge model
approving ordinary operations on the user's behalf. When the Judge's verdict
is `allow` and every fail-closed health gate in the Enforce truth table
passes (audit, telemetry, result kind, review acknowledgement,
generation-current), the command runs without the human dialog. The Judge can
never answer `deny` with authority; every uncertain case (defer, deny,
preflight, infrastructure failure) falls back to the human dialog.
_Avoid_: model safety certification (dropped — see ADR 0008), AI takeover,
auto-deny, full delegation
**Audit log (Judge-owned)**:
The Enforce-era accountability record written by the Judge package itself —
@@ -21,6 +26,16 @@ record, self-checked for health; an unhealthy audit log refuses authority.
_Avoid_: host contract (dropped — see ADR 0006), acknowledged write (upstream
sense)
**High-risk override**:
A narrow code-level preflight recognizing clear-cut command shapes in four
categories — data loss/history rewrite, publish/deploy/infrastructure
destruction, privilege escalation/system modification, direct credential
access — that always defers to the human dialog regardless of verdict. In
Enforce it skips the model call entirely; in Shadow the model is still called
for quality observation. Deliberately not a sandbox: only well-known explicit
shapes, no alias/script/variable analysis, no `alwaysPrompt` config.
_Avoid_: command sandbox, alwaysPrompt, opaque-command blanket defer
**Irreversibility boundary**:
An allow verdict requires every operation's effects to be recoverable —
reversible, or reproducible from the repository or the evidence at hand.